Just finished Skyward Sword.
What's good about it:
- Combat system
- Motion controls
- Difficulty
- The dungeons themselves
- Boss battles
- The story/ending
The bad (very minor spoilers):
There was 3 areas, forest, volcano, and desert. They reused these same 3 areas a lot. All areas are connected by a sky hub world, very similar to Windwaker's ocean. The entire game was basically you going between these 3 areas, and the starting town (the only town), in a very linear fashion.
Post too long. Click here to view the full text.