No.24266
A communist society is:
- moneyless (money doesn't exist)
- stateless (government doesn't exist)
- classless
Depending on what you mean by "class", most hunter-gatherer tribes of the past were communist.
They only thing I really can't see happening is the "classless" part.
Native Americans were communist, but you know the strongest best-looking guy got the most pussy. That puts him in a different "class".
Women would always be in a different "class" because of their mental and physical inferiority, and because they are inherently much more sexually valuable than men.
If there was a skilled doctor or architect, while he wouldn't be rewarded with money, because money doesn't exist, he would get rewarded with more respect from the community, he would get more gifts from the community, and be able to demand he gets pussy. This would put him in a different "class".
No.24285
>>24266no one would fuck him though, at least in this society they fuck him cuz he has money
No.24288
Architects are useless in a classless communist society. Their ability to make an aesthetically pleasing building has no value. Artistic and intellectual merits have no value if everyone is equal. Buildings would be designed by engineers to perform at maximum function
I would give my pussy to a doctor knowing he could save my life over some uneducated bum. Only a government could oversee aspects like this to keep men equal. Capitalism does a great job by exploiting our instincts to create a society where status and wealth can sastisfy our animalistic fears.
No.24289
>>24288We won't need workers once we have robot slaves
No.24291
>>24288Architects have existed for thousands of years.
They built the Pantheon.
A viking building a primitive longhouse was an architect.
Someone who knows how to build living dwelling of any kind would be highly valuable in a society without money.
No.24294
>>24288Why would somebody spend the years it takes to become a doctor if they did not receive financial compensation for it?
No.24295
>>24294Some people just like saving lives.
No.24296
>>24294You receive admiration, gifts, respect, reputation, and sex.
No.24297
>>24295You could become a firefighter or paramedic much easier and save lives too.
No.24299
>>24296You get all of those plus money in a capitalist society
No.24300
>>24297None of them have the expertise required to save someone with a deadly disease.
No.24301
>>24299Yes but you're ignoring all the other evil horrible shit that comes with living in a modern capitalist society.
Also you can't become a doctor in a capitalist society without already having money. You must be born privileged.
No.24302
>>24301You can do it my country without money.
No.24303
>>24302Your country is partially socialist.
Anyway capitalism causes massive suffering, not everyone can win, the majority has to be losers, basically either slaves or homeless, or else capitalism can't work.
You can't turn a modern capitalist society into one without money or government, it would mean complete civilizational collapse, the only solution is if you went back in time and never started capitalism (never invented money).
Why would you want money in a society where money doesn't exist? Imagine a pre-colonial Native American doctor, why would he want money? Do you think he wanted to live in a mansion with an expensive car, in exchange for extreme degeneracy, no community or social bonds, destroyed land, and while the other 90% of his people lived like shit, competing with each other over money for scraps, instead of collectively working together to live off the land?
No.24304
>>24301Bullshit, you can take out loan and work hard in America.
No.24305
>>24304>just take out student loans broHuge gamble. Medical careers are highly competed for.
You might get out of college with that medical degree, and never be able to get a job.
No.24306
>>24305Dumbest shit I've ever read. Medical profession is literally guaranteed job 😐 we always need hospitals
No.24308
>>24307That's literally just an internship not a real job
No.24309
>>24308Good luck getting a job if you can't even get an internship.
My point is there is people leaving colleges with $100,000+ debt, STEM or medical degrees, and can't get a job.
They kill themselves or work at Walmart and post on reddit.
No.24310
>>24309that link is from the uk not america. and the worst case scenario for those uk people is a year without a "job" i.e. finish their intern year. america doesn't have some internship shortage stop being so bitter that you didn't go into the medical field and doctors are making 500k a year while youre a neet bitter and angry so you want to steal their money with communism
No.24313
but whatever maybe it's something that's changed in the 2010s or something, i guess its possible, and if its true its something new, it was never like this before and probably due to western civilization becoming more and more communist
No.24314
>>24313If anything social safety nets are being dismantled everywhere in the western world.
No.24315
>>24314what ar social safety nets
No.24316
>>24315Stuff like unemployment benefits or universal healthcare or homeless shelters.
No.24317
can i still be a neet and watch anime all day in a communist society
No.24318
>>24317Working wouldn't be as bad. You'd have no reason not to want to work. You'd be desired, appreciated, and making useful contributions.
You can help with farming, or hunting, building houses, or making clothes.
It wouldn't be like having a job today, which is completely soul-crushing, like begging for the privilege to work at McDonalds, having to adhere to their dress codes, political correct policies, being completely disrespected, working strictly set hours, not having any real purpose, no job security, no community, no reason to work, living as a cog in a dsytopian capitalist machine.
No.24319
>>24318Work is terrible no matter where you are.
Also you would just be a cog in a communist machine instead of a capitalist one, at least I could spend my income on weeb things in a capitalist country.
No.24320
>>24318why would they be building houses in gulags
No.24321
>>24320Soviets never achieved communism. They still had money and government (obviously). It's not communism if there is a government.
The only currently existing communist societies today are uncontacted tribes, like the Sentinelese, or in the Amazon.
No.24322
>>24321What happens if you refuse to work in a commie society
No.24323
>>24321You could still say tribes have a system of government and money though, they have a chief who governs the tribe and they trade with each other, money is really just the evolution of the bartering system.
No.24326
>>24322People won't like you, might not give you food or help you. What happens to people who don't work in a capitalist society? Or can't work due to lack of jobs? Check out Skid Row LA.
Unless you're disabled, there's very little reason to not work in a communist society. It wouldn't be like the modern concept of work.
A pre-colonial Native American tribe hunting buffalo would be an example of "work" in a communist society.
The idea of turning a modern capitalist society into actual communism is extremely radical, it's basically anarchy.
Socialism is much more realistic, where you still have money and government, except it's spread around to prevent massive inequality.
>>24323It's not a formal government/state though. You could have chiefs or respected men who make decisions, but it doesn't mean you have a government.
No.24331
>>24326A government is a group of people with the authority to govern over a country, state or whatever. A chief and his retainers would constitute a government, just a very primitive one but then it is a primitive society.